People I know

Friday, August 26, 2005

Who am I?

The compilation of different judgements passed on me over the years:

Tenth standard:

Teacher A: "Manda ganam Pidichavan da nee" (You are very head strong)
Teacher A: "PB, I wish you score a state rank"

Teacher B: "Intha Vayasilaye shavinga..urupada maata, rowdya thiriya pora" (You shaved at this age, I can see you becoming a rowdy soon)
Teacher B: "Paravalla Nalla than Padikira, nalla mark than, namma school ku ithu athigam" (Guess you study well, considering our school standard you did well in the exam)

My sanskrit teacher: "There wont be a class if pb is absent, he is my pet student"

Eleventh and Twelfth standard:

Teacher C: "I can see that you have capability to score state rank, you are very brilliant"

Teacher D: "You acted well in the drama as 80 year old man. Given your avaerage performance in studies better you try an acting career"

Teacher G: "PB has good general knowledge and he is a good actor on stage. Definetly a good student"

Teacher E: "Muthukumar Mannangatti Kumar" on my score of 2/50 in botony

Teacher F: " Why did you not pay the fees for science talent test. Dont think your low scoring in exams means Poor dtudent. I really like your attitude towards studies. You raise good questions in the class. I am paying you for the exam, please take it" ( I did not take the exam eventually though. You long live Sir!)

Teacher E: "You are a shame to our school"

Teacher E: (when I was about to enter exam hall for 12th std exam) "I think you really need not take the exam. I am sure you will not pass and ours is a school of rank holders, I am afraid you will spoil our 100% result record"

Teacher E: (When I scored 93% in 12th stad: botony exam) "Sheer luck"

Teacher C: "Very good you scored well in public exam"

During BE:

Teacher H: "Mariyathai theriyatha payan, even in first year his behaviour is very bad. Fellow teachers beware of him"

Teacher H: "Sorry I mistook him, avan padikira payan"

Teacher I: "You are a total introvert"

Teacher J: "You are a total extravert"

Teacher K: " Muthukumar, please know that what you know is very less, you might be raising good questions in the class room, but please be respectful for my education and experience"

Teacher K: "How are you progressing in you "Naan-Yaar" Vicahara marga"

Teacher L: "Muthukumar, you are arrogant, get out of the class"

Teacher L: "My class will start only muthukumar leaves, this is a rule" (later lifted)

Teacher L: "I dont like your change as calm student, I liked you better when you were playing pranks in my class and was sent out always. Be happy always. Dont be worried or thinking" (L was a lady staff)

Teacher M: "Even though your batch had many brilliant students, I will always remember how PB did that DPSK circuit with a simple resister and diode. Never seen anybody being so creative during exams" (on our farewall, our communications system staff).

So many teachers have said so many things all along, opinions varying from one end of the spectrum to other. I am not sure which of them were true and which of them were not. I salute them for their inputs though. Same goes to every person. People just keep on saying opinions about one and none of them are absolutely right. Opinions are framed from the stand point of the seer.


Similarly goes a stanza in abirami anthathi which says all things attributed to mother godess like, Deer like eyes, lotus like bossoms all are laughable and one has to stay away from all these imaginations and think of her true nature.

"நகையே இது, இந்த ஞாலம்
எல்லாம் பெற்ற நாயகிக்கு,
முகையே முகிழ் முலை, மானே,
முது கண் முடிவுயில், அந்த
வகையே பிறவியும், வம்பே,
மலைமகள் என்பதும் நாம்,
மிகையே இவள்தன் தகைமையை
நாடி விரும்புவதே!

In nutshell, one has to have a holistic approach when we try to analyse anything or anyone. Before trying to do such analysis on anything else, let us start on our own self!.

16 Comments:

  • Nice compilation.

    I am sure you can do the same compilation with your relatives as the "opinion makers".

    "Opinions are framed from the stand point of the seer."

    Couple of things:
    1) Opinions are framed not only from the view point of the opinion maker but also the viewed person's presentation-of-oneself at that time.

    Depending upon my view but also your behaviour at that time. This keeps on changing when either or both of these variables change, one variable influences the other.

    2) Is "seer" the suitable term here?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:46 PM  

  • 1) I still feel opinions are framed only from viewres perspective. For e.g. a criminal son is always good for his mother. IN love people fail to see each others fault etc. I think you know the story in mahabharath where yudhisthra is not able to find single bad person in this world and duryodhana did not find a single good one.

    2) "seer" here is one who "sees".

    By Blogger P B, at 11:57 AM  

  • Opinions are of course formed from the point of view of the seer. Heisenberg's uncertainty principle applies here to some extent. The observer affects the observed in many ways. For example, if X comes to know from a third party that Y thinks X is a very talkative person, then X will try to be talkative in Y's presence. To that extent, Y's assumption about him has colored X's behavior. This is true for more complex and unexplainable actions too :)But, instead of forming instant judgements, if we give it time the opinion will be more accurate.

    By Blogger The Doodler, at 7:06 AM  

  • Since there is a technical discussion on the "color" of opinion I am going to make it more colored.

    Any opinion has some 'color' to it. By the way of Central Limit Theorem, the more the color, the random variable(opinion) becomes Gaussian. Gaussian form has the most uncertainity/entropy associated with it.

    So by this rationale, the more time
    we take to form a opinion,the more it gets colored and hence loaded with more uncertainity. So people make instantaneous judgement.

    -vv

    Don't blame me for this mumbo jumbo.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:40 AM  

  • @V V

    If ppl forms a opinion that you are a geek from this comment who is to be blamed?

    By Blogger P B, at 9:44 AM  

  • If that's made in an instantaneous time .. it might probably be have less noise. :)

    As time grows, well my theory stays.. and their opinion ..its their problem.

    -vv

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:12 AM  

  • If only human relationships were as easy to describe as a mathematical model, VV, we'd all have a formula by now..:)I'd be more inclined toward Chaos Theory and Fractals to describe human relations..Like they say in the Butterfly Effect, you never know how one seemingly innocent word or one glance might have an adverse effect somewhere else (especially with girls..)LOL

    By Blogger The Doodler, at 11:10 AM  

  • PB,

    back to business? intha maaberum karuthai therivikka "abirami anthathi" slokam..bale, bale.

    1. Opinions are framed from the stand point of the seer.

    I totally agree. We are so used to discerning the good/bad extremeties
    that there would be multiple notions of the same thing. A good exercise to try out, would be to closely watch ourselves how we judge given the situation as to where a thought bubbles from..

    2. "one has to have a holistic approach when we try to analyse anything or anyone"

    This is ideal but highly impossible unless one is at the stage of getting into the subjective thinking..like salt dissolved in water - at which point there is only one thing (to some), except thought otherwise (to others) that salt exists apart from water due to its taste, etc. (I remember reading this somewhere...)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:14 PM  

  • hmnn pb!!!
    ivlo pera kaduppu ethi irukkenga.. evlo pera sandhosha paduthiirukeenga...ithanaiyum nyabagamum vechuirukeenga!!!



    ivlo ellam teacherum en kooda pesinathu illa.. nanum avanga kooda pesinathum illa!!

    By Blogger Maayaa, at 12:42 AM  

  • addhu sari Muthukumar,
    nee nallavvanna, kettavanna ?
    :-) unngga teachers comments lla errundhhu conclude panna mudiyalaiyye.....

    By Blogger Viji Sundararajan, at 7:17 AM  

  • theriyalaye maa..(velu nayakar)

    By Blogger P B, at 8:19 AM  

  • Looks like we've had a very similar school and college life!! Thanks for visiting my BLOG

    By Blogger Agnibarathi, at 1:10 AM  

  • Botany -a botony nu solra ungaluku 2/50 too much. -2 kuduthu irukanum.

    By Blogger Freeyavedu, at 5:49 PM  

  • pb,

    nice post man.... i guess these things have happened to most people but only few like you take in the right sense and even go to the extent of seeing the humour and wisdom in it... hmm... really interesting...

    oru vagayil naanum appidithan.. :)

    btw, yaaru indha sridhar.... he commented on mine too.. but could not trace to his blog.. hehe...bayangar ushar paarty pola...or is it ur cousin ?

    By Blogger Zeppelin, at 8:08 AM  

  • Sridhar ennoda cousin than. Namma nerla eppidi irunthalum blogla ippodi pubagzthupom mama..nalla iruku ithu!..
    Nee oru genius nu summva sonnanga!

    By Blogger P B, at 4:51 PM  

  • naan oru genius nu sollitangalaa... yaaru andha punniyavaan/punniyavathi.. ? :)

    illa neeyave build uttute na... God Bless You !

    cheers!

    By Blogger Zeppelin, at 1:23 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home